A row has broken out between the UK and Scottish governments over funding for the Acorn Carbon Capture and Storage Project, after SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn accused Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer of a “betrayal” over changes to the scheme’s financial backing.
Martin McCluskey, the Labour MP for Inverclyde and a minister at the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, has written to the Scottish Government in response to Flynn’s comments, warning that public criticism of the project risks undermining investor confidence.
The dispute centres on a £200 million grant committed by ministers last year to support Acorn, which is based at the St Fergus gas terminal in Aberdeenshire and is intended to be one of the UK’s flagship carbon capture and storage schemes.
This week’s Budget documents revealed that the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero would redirect spending towards defence, with £200 million understood to be saved from the UK’s wider carbon capture programme. The government said it was instead examining the use of loans or equity investment to support Acorn’s development.
Flynn used a video posted on social media to accuse the Prime Minister of reneging on a prior commitment to the project, prompting a swift rebuttal from UK ministers, who insist funding has not been withdrawn.
Treasury Chief Secretary Emma Reynolds told BBC Scotland that the government remains committed to Acorn. “We’re not cutting the grant funding and we will probably need to look at some sort of financial transactions to secure the rest of the project,” she said.
In his letter to Flynn, McCluskey echoed that position, arguing that a shift in the structure of government investment “should not be presented as the removal” of support for Acorn, though he acknowledged that any further financial transactions would “need to see the taxpayer receive a return”.
He warned that Scottish Government commentary could “undermine confidence” in the project “at precisely the point when we should be helping the project secure the investment and partnerships it needs”, adding: “I urge you to avoid talking the project down and to make clear that there remains a route to further government support.”
The exchange follows separate comments from Scottish Secretary Douglas Alexander, who pointed to ongoing issues around Acorn’s commercial arrangements and the maturity of the carbon capture technology it depends on.
In Case You Missed it:
Confusion over Acorn funding prompts calls for UK Government clarity
Aberdeen council co-leader defies No-Confidence vote as row escalates
GB Energy Aberdeen jobs row erupts after over a third of workforce ‘refuse to relocate’
Aberdeen education officials condemn “weaponisation of Christmas” after Kaimhill cards row
Also speaking to the BBC, Scottish Government minister Jenny Gilruth called for “certainty and clarity” from the UK Government over its continued support for the scheme, reflecting broader frustration in Edinburgh over what officials see as shifting signals from Westminster.
Carbon capture and storage is viewed as a critical technology in the UK’s efforts to meet its net zero targets, with projects such as Acorn designed to capture emissions from industrial sites and store them underground. The scheme has long been positioned as central to decarbonising Scotland’s north-east, a region heavily reliant on the oil and gas sector.
Both governments say they remain committed to the project’s long-term success, though the disagreement over funding mechanisms highlights continuing tension between Holyrood and Westminster over the pace and structure of net zero investment.




