SSEN has secured Scottish Government approval for its contentious Hurlie substation in Fetteresso Forest, overturning a decision by Aberdeenshire Council to block the scheme.
The 400kV facility, named after a nearby bog, represents the energy firm’s revised proposal following the abandonment of earlier plans for a substation at Fiddes three years ago. The Hurlie scheme attracted fierce opposition, with more than 2,000 objections lodged with the local authority amid claims it amounted to the “wrong development in the wrong place”.
Aberdeenshire councillors rejected SSEN’s application near Stonehaven in January following a seven-hour debate, despite the company’s argument that the substation was essential for strengthening the grid and facilitating offshore wind connections, including the Kintore to Tealing overhead line. Councillors had expressed concern that the development would alter the character of the forest and risk “industrialisation of the area”.
Undeterred, SSEN lodged an appeal with the Scottish Government in March, a move that has now resulted in ministerial approval, paving the way for construction to proceed.
Reporter’s findings
The appeal was assessed by Alasdair Edwards, a reporter with the government’s Planning and Environmental Appeals Division, who visited the site and reviewed submissions from SSEN, the council and objectors before concluding there were “no material considerations which would justify refusing to grant planning permission”.
In his report, Mr Edwards noted that Fetteresso Forest had been selected “due to having the least environmental constraints, despite technical and cost implications”, adding: “Therefore, in order to fulfil the requirement for future grid connections of renewable energy, the Hurlie Substation serves a clear need.”
He judged the proposed design “functional and appropriate” and the chosen location “acceptable”, concluding that planned landscaping would limit the development’s visual impact over time. “The significant landscape and visual effects would be experienced from a very few locations and localised with design mitigation applied,” he wrote.
Wildlife concerns addressed
Objectors had also raised fears over potential harm to wildlife, including the Scottish crossbill. SSEN had previously confirmed it would carry out surveys covering all bird species and had developed a bird protection plan in consultation with NatureScot, the government’s wildlife agency.
An environmental impact assessment report submitted by SSEN appears to have satisfied these concerns. Mr Edwards concluded there would be “no significant effects” on protected species such as bats, badgers, wildcats, red squirrels and pine martens, despite some habitat loss. He added that ongoing species protection plans, surveying and monitoring would have a “positive beneficial effect”.
In Case You Missed it:
The reporter also accepted the assessment’s findings of “no significant cumulative effects in relation to hydrology, hydrogeology, peat or soil”, along with no significant noise or vibration impacts during construction or operation.
Second substation looms
The ruling emerges just hours before Aberdeenshire councillors are due to debate a separate proposal for a second substation in Fetteresso Forest. The infrastructure services committee will meet to consider plans by Thistle Wind Partners for onshore facilities linked to its Bowdun Offshore Wind Farm, including an export cable landing at Haughs Bay near Benholm.
Councillors previously expressed frustration that planning rules prevented them from assessing the Bowdun scheme alongside Hurlie in a combined context.






